So I was asked today, what would you do? And since I don’t have the answer, I’m asking you. Maybe then I can give the answer. Yes, I will give credit to you. It’s only fair.
A friend asked me this week what I would do if I was faced with knowing something, but not being able to tell the your significant other about. Because it’s about them. She needed to know, the neighbors said, because she lives with him. Committed to him. But her significant other can’t know. He can’t know that a comment he made, in a drunken state, has essentially alienated him from his neighbors. That while the neighbors understand he was drunk when he said what he considered a joke, was not taken as one. That they were offended and now somewhat concerned to be around him. While they don’t think he would ever do anything, they trust him that much, but there is still a doubt. A worry. A concern.
See, he said something inappropriate about a neighbor’s 16 year old daughter. To the 16 year old daughter’s over-protective dad. The dad obviously did not take too kindly to this comment. And now the neighbors, who still want to be polite and waive as they drive by and talk if he comes over, don’t really want him coming over and talking and hanging out. That seed has been planted. They don’t want it getting back to him because they all live in the same neighborhood. But she needed to know. Now she is faced with knowing, but not being able to tell him why the neighbors may not talk or hang out too much.
She asked, what would you do? What would I do if I had something like that told to me about S and I couldn’t tell him? Holy hell! I have no idea. I wouldn’t want that burden placed on me. To have to keep a secret from the person you love. Living each day with this person whose neighbors no longer completely trust him. Wondering what they are thinking each time that all the neighbors do happen to get together. I told her I think I would rather not know. That in my opinion, it probably would have been best if both of them were kept in the dark.
But it’s too late. She already knows. And now she doesn’t know what to do. Should she be honest with the man she is committed to? The one she knows honestly would never do a thing to a child. But nevertheless, the one who drunkenly made a stupid comment.
On one hand, I say, share the information. This is your husband we are talking about. You don’t keep secrets from each other. On the other hand, the neighbors shared this so that you would know why they were possibly shunning both of you, if he was around. They confided in you. They don’t want to ruin the vibe of the neighborhood. They trust you not to say anything.
All I could say, was I’m glad it’s not me. Which was of no help to her, I realize that. But I didn’t have the answers. Or at least one I thought was worthy of sharing. But what do you say? What do you tell your friend, who confided this in you, to do? I still don’t have the answer.
